Isn't cppreference quite clear about what clear() does?

Erases all elements from the container. After this call, size() returns zero.

Invalidates any references, pointers, and iterators referring to contained elements. Any past-the-end iterators are also invalidated.

it never specifies anything about releasing memory, or resetting values.

Best,

Rhidian

Op di 7 okt 2025 om 22:12 schreef Jerome Saint-Martin via Std-Proposals <std-proposals@lists.isocpp.org>:

Motivation

In the Standard Template Library (STL), the clear() function is defined for containers like std::vector, std::deque, and others. Its behavior is functionally equivalent to:

container.erase(container.begin(), container.end());

It removes all elements from the container, reducing its size() to zero, but does not release memory (capacity remains unchanged), nor does it reset values. This leads to a subtle redundancy in the API: clear() is essentially a shorthand for a full-range erase().

Observation

While clear() is widely used and syntactically convenient, it introduces a semantic ambiguity. Many developers — especially those new to C++ — assume clear() “resets” the container’s values. In reality, it destroys the elements, not reinitializes them.

This confusion is compounded by the fact that clear() does not offer anything beyond what erase(begin(), end()) already provides.

Too Much Progress Kills the Progress

In the early days of programming, we used erase(begin(), end()) like our ancestors used silex to make fire. It was precise, intentional, and part of the craft. Then came clear() — a smoother, more modern tool. But in simplifying, we may have blurred its purpose. Today, we have expressive tools like resize(n, val), ranges, and lambdas.

Proposal

• Option A (radical):
• Deprecate or remove clear() from STL containers where it is strictly equivalent to erase(begin(), end())
• reclaim clear() for a more meaningful role — resetting vector values to a default value, like resize(n, val) does — and let erase(begin(), end()) remain the sharp silex in our toolbox.
• Option B (soft): Clarify in the standard documentation that clear() is a semantic alias for erase(begin(), end()), and does not reset values or release memory.

std::co_proposers :: Jérôme Saint-Martin and friend Beg Copilot

--
Std-Proposals mailing list
Std-Proposals@lists.isocpp.org
https://lists.isocpp.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/std-proposals

--

Rhidian De Wit

Software Engineer - Barco