C++ Logo

sg16

Advanced search

SG16 meeting summary for February 2nd, 2023

From: Tom Honermann <tom_at_[hidden]>
Date: Thu, 16 Feb 2023 15:40:52 -0500
The summary for the SG16 meeting held February 2nd, 2023 is now
available. For those that attended, please review and suggest corrections.

  * https://github.com/sg16-unicode/sg16-meetings#february-2nd-2023

The following polls were taken:

  * Poll 1.1: P2749R0 "Down with 'character'" should be included in the
    IS only if the updates to whitespace specification described in
    P2348 "Whitespaces Wording Revamp" are also included.
      o Attendees: 7 (1 abstention)
      o
        SF
         F
         N
         A
         SA
        0
         4
         1
         0
         1

      o Weak consensus.
  * Poll 1.2: Forward P2749R0 "Down with 'character'", revised as
    discussed, to CWG for C++23 as the recommended resolution of ballot
    comment FR-020-014.
      o Attendees: 7
      o
        SF
         F
         N
         A
         SA
        1
         1
         3
         2
         0

      o No consensus.
  * Poll 1.3: Recommend rejection of ballot comment FR-020-014 as no
    consensus for change.
      o Attendees: 7 (1 abstention)
      o
        F
         N
         A
        4
         1
         1

      o Consensus.

The polls were recorded in the following GitHub issue trackers. An issue
tracker for P2749 has not yet been created since the paper has not yet
appeared in a mailing. I'll add the polls to it once created.

  * NBBallot issue #422
    <https://github.com/cplusplus/nbballot/issues/422>: FR-020-014 5.3
    [lex.charset] Replace "translation character set" by "Unicode" P2749

Please note that the decision not to forward P2749R0 at this time is
due, at least partially, to the lack of time to properly review it for
the C++23 deadline. SG16 will continue to review this paper with a
presumed target of C++26.

Tom.

Received on 2023-02-16 20:40:53