Subject: Re: Bike shedding for Christmas: P1885 Naming Text Encodings
From: Corentin Jabot (corentinjabot_at_[hidden])
Date: 2020-01-04 09:32:00
On Sat, 4 Jan 2020 at 15:12, Thiago Macieira via SG16 <sg16_at_[hidden]>
> On Tuesday, 31 December 2019 20:49:00 -03 Tom Honermann via SG16 wrote:
> > The benefit is that including all of them avoids the problem of
> > implementors offering extensions with inconsistent or conflicting
> > names. It also doesn't put us in the position of deciding which
> > encodings are "important". IANA provides a good specification to
> > follow. I don't think we should be subsetting, at least not without
> > some clear criteria for determining which encodings make the cut. For
> > example, I suspect Shift-JIS gets more use than UTF-32, but the former
> > is not included in the proposal and the latter is.
> I say we should bite that bullet and make the list of what we think should
> available as constexpr-time constants: 7-bit US-ASCII, Latin1, UTF-8,
> UTF-32. Plus something to indicate "System" (locale encoding). No more.
> If someone needs a full listing, they can take the XML file from IANA and
> generate their list converting from MIB to all names and aliases. The C++
> standard doesn't need to do that for them.
> Besides, what are the IDs to be used for? To access an encoder and a
> Aside from those 6 above, everything else, including unregistered names,
> aliases and extensions, is optional to all implementations and must be
> for at runtime. Relying on them existing is not portable.
Comparison.... basically the only use (2 text encoding with the same mib
are identical, although the primary iana name might do), and you can
compare a MiB to a text_encoding directly.
I still think it's useful to have a method that gives you the mib when it
is known so you can interface with a few libraries that use it.
But beyond that I don't think we should focus on MiB.
Otherwise I agree, an implementation needs to only provide the encoding it
(important for embedded platforms where the encoding never changes)
> Thiago Macieira - thiago (AT) macieira.info - thiago (AT) kde.org
> Software Architect - Intel System Software Products
> SG16 mailing list
SG16 list run by herb.sutter at gmail.com